the_dala: made by iconzicons (Default)
Add MemoryShare This Entry
posted by [personal profile] the_dala at 05:15pm on 16/11/2005
Last spring, I wrote an essay for my Modern Religious Thought course about Martin Luther King Jr. and Dietrich Bonhoeffer as prophets according to the Old Testament tradition. The professor gave me an A, pointed it out in class as publishable, and suggested I submit it to the school's philosophy journal. I did, and it was accepted and published, and that was very cool.

Today in class I got the following e-mail from Katharina:

I wanted you to submit your published essay to a conservative Christian foundation that offers $ 10,000 to an essay that quotes the Bible and is published in a secular journal. I think you qualify, the foundation is called amyfoundtn@aol.com. What do you think?

I looked up the foundation and perused their website, which contains additional information about this writing contest (in addition to the $10,000 first prize, there is a second prize of $5000, third prize of $4000, fourth prize of $3000, fifth prize of $2000, and ten $1000 prizes). It does look as though my essay would qualify, and it is certainly good enough to hold up to the winners from last year (although those mostly seem to be personal accounts, and mine is a persuasive essay). I don't think it's conceited to say so. I give good papers; I know when I have written something worthy and when I've produced total crap. This essay was the best paper I wrote last year, next to the Frankenstein birth/creation metaphor paper. I wouldn't even consider submitting it unless I thought it had a decent shot at winning some prize.

All that said, I doubt there is a single person who is reading this or has ever been acquainted me who does not see the problem here.

I could really use that money. I could use any one of those prizes, and badly. I won't have a chance to work this summer because I'll be doing the field school here, in theory, and we are already scrambling around trying to figure out how to pay for that. But my moral compass does not point in the direction of this foundation's mission statement.

I wish I could say definitively that that means I won't consider submitting the essay. Conversely, I wish I could say that I would submit it with absolutely no qualms. I can say that I would be able to live with myself, using a conservative Christian foundation's prize money to help fund my education and my own personal liberal agenda. I can say that the thought of doing so makes my insides feel funny. I can say that I believe my essay reflects the reality that one does not need to be religious in order to find faith inspiring, and I would be proud to defend that position.

Just...if I won, would I have to go to some kind of ceremony and stand up in front of these people and practice a 'don't ask, don't tell' policy regarding my own total lack of belief? Would I put this on graduate school applications? I think the practical aspects really confound me as much or more than the moral...If I used some of the money to make donations to the Democratic Party, to GLAAD, to NOW, etc., would that make me feel like more or less of a horrible person?

Gahhhh. I am going to the gym to work off frustration and the Coke and KitKat I felt compelled to consume after reading the e-mail in the middle of class.

Please, y'all, leave me your honest thoughts on this. I can post the essay if that would make things clearer. I'm going to talk to my parents and Megan and Katherine later. But probably not Vanessa, aye?

Jesus H. Roosevelt Christ. iTunes is now playing "Don't Let Me Be Misunderstood." Cheeky little bastard thinks it's funny.
Music:: i'm just a soul whose intentions are good
Mood:: 'distressed' distressed
There are 24 comments on this entry. (Reply.)
 
posted by [identity profile] cjk1701.livejournal.com at 10:30pm on 16/11/2005
Don't know if my ramblings help at all, but when I was in San Diego on my high school exchange year, I participated in an essay contest sponsored by an US WWII veterans' group. The essay was on the Second Amendment, and I wrote predictable critical stuff about strict firearm control. I disagreed with the group's ethics and with the spirit behind the essay prompt, but I still entered.

Basically I think if there's a group willing to pay money for your article, you should contribute it and let them decide if they should take you. I'd say go for the money instead of the principles. A neutral paper does not endorse their beliefs, even if they're prepared to pay for it.
ext_15529: made by jazsekuhsjunk (ezekielbpenguin - the notebook)
posted by [identity profile] the-dala.livejournal.com at 02:03am on 17/11/2005
Okay. Yeah. That helps. Thank you :)
(deleted comment)
 
posted by [identity profile] tiggothy.livejournal.com at 10:44pm on 16/11/2005
Seconded. Check them out. Though if they're in any way trying to do the dirty on people by making entry / winning dependant on any condition other than an essay's academic worthiness? Let us know who they are so we can ridcule & vilify them* ;-)

*Please take note of the text of my icon in regard to this proposition
ext_15529: made by jazsekuhsjunk (greenabsinthe -- pinup dala)
posted by [identity profile] the-dala.livejournal.com at 02:11am on 17/11/2005
Hee. Thank you.

There are...expressions of religion necessary for the entry, but my essay has those. I don't, necessarily, but I figure that's not the point.
ext_15529: made by jazsekuhsjunk (greenabsinthe - aly)
posted by [identity profile] the-dala.livejournal.com at 02:01am on 17/11/2005
I Googled them and found a link from the Michigan State Universty Library website, under Funding, as well as a bunch of Christian websites; they appear to be perfectly legitimate. Thank you about the copyright issue -- that hadn't occurred to me. I'm going to e-mail the foundation for more information.
 
posted by [identity profile] elessil.livejournal.com at 10:54pm on 16/11/2005
I can only second what has been said. Quite frankly, if you can use the money for your education, go for it. Check into their terms... is there in any way stated that you need to believe in their ideals to participate?
ext_15529: made by jazsekuhsjunk (findme_icons - ducky)
posted by [identity profile] the-dala.livejournal.com at 02:12am on 17/11/2005
Not specifically. Certain themes must be expressed in the entry -- "the need for obedience through biblical truth should be evident," which is is -- but nothing dictating personal beliefs.
 
posted by [identity profile] elessil.livejournal.com at 08:20am on 17/11/2005
Then I'd go for it. Check the copyright matter, as others have said, but if the need for belief need be expressed only in the essay, then go for it. You're not lying with that or pretending anything. The essay is what it is, if they're not asking about your personal belief, it's not your part to tell them.
 
posted by [identity profile] veronica-rich.livejournal.com at 11:07pm on 16/11/2005
If there's one thing I've learned in 33 years, it's that you take your professional honors where you can get them. If you win and have to go to a big gathering, I wouldn't expect you to lie; just tell people your faith is very personal to you, that your parents taught you to be that way. You won't be the first non-Xtian to get a Xtian award, trust me. I don't believe you're required to be one of the faithful; the only way to find out, though, is to send for an application or guidelines.

I had to go to an extremely pro-Xtian thing not too long ago, to write about it. At the end, we were all brought into this big tent for a short sermon about accepting Jesus into our lives. At one point we had to close our eyes and bow our heads (except for the minister and his lackeys) and were asked various questions, such as "How many of you came here tonight with Jesus already in your heart?" and "Who of you here would like more information on this?" and such. The questions were phrased such that if you didn't raise your hand to ANY of them, you looked weird. I stood there the entire time, eyes closed, head bowed, and kept my arms down, with a smile on my face. I don't know how many other people kept their hands down, if any.
ext_15529: made by jazsekuhsjunk (susanweise - teh smile)
posted by [identity profile] the-dala.livejournal.com at 02:13am on 17/11/2005
That made me smile. Thank you.
 
posted by [identity profile] dejectedmadness.livejournal.com at 11:18pm on 16/11/2005
Wow. I can totally see how you would have a hard time deciding this, though if it were me, I would completely and without guilt submit the essay and win the money and then just go on my merry way. However, this seems to be really bothering you in a moral sort of way.
I would say that the contest, since the rules don't state that you need to be of the same faith, you should go for it. Just do it. If you have a valid use for the money, I don't see anything wrong with it.
ext_15529: made by jazsekuhsjunk (fufu_icons - gilda radner)
posted by [identity profile] the-dala.livejournal.com at 02:18am on 17/11/2005
I'm going to submit it. If I win, I'll just...get over the whole moral objection thing :)
(deleted comment)
ext_15529: made by jazsekuhsjunk (Default)
posted by [identity profile] the-dala.livejournal.com at 02:22am on 17/11/2005
Augh, thank you Lin. I think I was worried about my own moral compunctions over supporting this organization, but if the only real support is financial, it's kind of the other way 'round.
 
posted by [identity profile] zarahemla.livejournal.com at 12:59am on 17/11/2005
I wouldn't do it. Myself, I couldn't take money from someone whose values so disagreed with my own. I'm a libertarian Christian, so I wouldn't take money from The Blue State Commission, or The International Council of Atheists, or whatever. Not cause they're So Wrong, but because I disagree with their beliefs and I wouldn't want them bankrollin' me.

It's a lot of money, and I wouldn't want to fund myself with it, even in the name of Enlightening the Poor Blinded Masses or Preventing the Use Of It To Fund The Thing I Disagree With, or whatever reason you care to tack onto it. That all seems like justification to me. If you take $10,000 on false pretences, you're taking it on false pretences, no matter how elaborate or good-intentioned they are.

But perhaps like a poster above said, they don't care about your personal beliefs, as long as they like what you put onto the paper. In which case, I'd go for it, because if they don't care, you shouldn't care either.
ext_15529: made by jazsekuhsjunk (Default)
posted by [identity profile] the-dala.livejournal.com at 02:41am on 17/11/2005
They care about beliefs insofar as the essay goes. I feel that I can make legitimate biblical arguments regardless of whether I personally believe in the Bible as the word of God.

...think I've talked myself into it...
 
posted by [identity profile] captsparrow4evr.livejournal.com at 04:24am on 17/11/2005
I would enter, especially since you've done some research and know they are legit. Let's face it, there's no guarantee you'll win (though they'd be idiots not to give it to you;) so you may be in this quandary for nothing. OTOH, if you don't enter, you will regret it because you definitely don't stand a chance of winning any of that prize money if you don't enter. Enter. If they ask you to sign something in order to get your prize money, read it carefully and have a law student take a look at it too. Then, when you have the money, remember that, if Jesus were here today, he'd be a rainbow-wearing, Affirmative Action-supporting, bleeding heart, pro-choice, anti-death sentence liberal, probably in the process of being seriously investigated by the FBI/CIA/Dept. of Homeland Security for his subversive opinions and Middle Eastern background.

Does that help?;) (Note: I'm using the only icon I have in which I, personally, appear--therefore, you must trust me.;)
 
posted by [identity profile] subversivecynic.livejournal.com at 04:35am on 17/11/2005
I'm going to offer you my experience. It might help you, it might irritate you. But an offer none the less.

I went to an incredibly right wing school. Antioch College. Your parent's will have heard of it. I was very happy there, until Antioch did something really bad to me, and expelled me. (This was the result of my having said an unpopular thing about race relations on campus. It was... unpleasant, and really disasterous.) The expulsion was undertaken in such a way that I cannot return to school. Most colleges will not accept me, and I lost my financial aide.

I was offered a lawsuite backed by a very conservative group, and refused to accept it, even if it would have won me my right to continue my education. I felt it would be wrong to accept the help of people who would shun my friends for their beliefs, race, or sexuality. I used all my own money fighting it, and when that ran out, went on with life without a degree, or any really hope of getting one.

I regret this descision more than almost anything else in my life. I would do almost anything to be given the oportunity to pursue my future. And those people would have been helping me do it.

I know it's important to make wise descisions. But think ahead about what you do. You never know when those people you shun would/could/should help you and the benefit would be mutual.
 
posted by [identity profile] subversivecynic.livejournal.com at 04:36am on 17/11/2005
left wing. Antioch is remarkably leftist. I don't know how I managed to say that, save I've been up 36 hours.
ext_15529: made by jazsekuhsjunk (dorothy - fortunateizzi3)
posted by [identity profile] the-dala.livejournal.com at 05:19pm on 17/11/2005
Thank you for the relation of that story. What an awful thing to have to go through.
 
posted by [identity profile] guede-mazaka.livejournal.com at 06:05am on 17/11/2005
So it looks like one, you've already gotten a lot of good advice, and two, you seem to be near to/have made a decision. I'm just going to say--the measure should be if you're comfortable with it, if you can sleep with what you choose to do, and not how comfortable we are with it. It's your work, your life and your moral code; we're only in a position to advise, not to dictate. And hopefully we don't try to, either.
ext_15529: made by jazsekuhsjunk (me - curious snake)
posted by [identity profile] the-dala.livejournal.com at 05:20pm on 17/11/2005
Oh no, I didn't mean to ask that. I was just so completely thrown by this yesterday and needed to bounce off of other people before making up my mind.
 
posted by [identity profile] guede-mazaka.livejournal.com at 08:09pm on 17/11/2005
Well, I just wanted to make sure it got said. I know in this kind of situation, a lot of people tend to try and foist their own moral code onto a person regardless of how comfortable that person ultimately is with it.
 
posted by [identity profile] ex-galadhir.livejournal.com at 10:43am on 17/11/2005
I'm a firm believer in the idea that the work stands up for itself and has little to nothing to do with either its creator or the people who read it. Is it true? Is it your real opinion? Then it doesn't matter a jot who likes it enough to pay you for it. And if you do win, and there is some kind of ceremony, you can always decline to go.
ext_15529: made by jazsekuhsjunk (me - horatio study)
posted by [identity profile] the-dala.livejournal.com at 05:21pm on 17/11/2005
Good point. Thank you :)

January

SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
1
 
2
 
3 4
 
5 6
 
7
 
8
 
9
 
10
 
11
 
12
 
13
 
14
 
15
 
16
 
17
 
18
 
19
 
20 21
 
22
 
23
 
24
 
25
 
26
 
27
 
28
 
29
 
30
 
31